Top 10 Best Pizza Spots in New York City

This blog post uncovers the Top 10 Best Pizza Spots in New York City.

What’s the first thing that comes to mind about NYC? For many, it’s the NYC Pizza. From classical slices to spicy tastings, NYC has the best pizza spots to try out.

This guide explores the top spots that produce Best Pizza in New York City—the city’s most mouthwatering slices.

L’industrie Pizzeria

This pizza restaurant has a Google rating of 4.7 stars after over 3k reviews.

If you are hunting for the best NYC Pizza, L’industrie Pizzeria should top your list. This hidden gem has a beautiful outdoor setting, and its service options are worth trying. Their signature pepperoni is finely crafted with crisped edges and a layer of spicy toppings.

When it comes to the sauce, they never fumble here! You gotta try their ever-serious creamy mozzarella cheese for that flavor and freshness. When you order, be sure to get the best pizza. Whether you are a veggie or meaty person, you’ll get the best. Pizza prices per person range from $10–20.

L’industrie Pizzeria Address

254 S 2nd St, Brooklyn, NY 11211

L’industrie Pizzeria Contacts

+1 (718)-599-0002

Scarr’s Pizza

Its google rating is 4.5 stars after more than 3500 reviews.

Scarr’s is ideally famous for lovers due to its cozy setting. When I last walked in here, I was welcomed by the smell of freshly baked thin crust. Behind the counter, I could spot the dough being spread by hand, a testament to delivering fresh products only. They tried to put their Margherita, crispy enough and finely spread with rich tomato sauce, at a far fresh, fragrant basil and mozzarella accompanied every bite.

If you are coming with friends or decide to sit down while having the pizza, you had better make a reservation early. Their prices run from a dollar to ten.

Scarr’s Pizza Address

35 Orchard St, New York, NY 10002

Scarr’s Pizza Contacts

+1 (212)-334-3481

Prince Street Pizza

It has a Google rating of 4.4 after more than 7500 reviews.

While their prices are affordable to the lowest of people, you must enjoy trying this hidden gem. Their specialty is pan pizza, buttery crust with gooey cheese, and spicy homemade pepperoni. When you taste any of their flavors, it tastes super fresh, and the texture of the dough is very crunchy and soft.

They also have creative options; you can’t resist the Buffalo Chicken Pizza! For those late-night cravings, at Price Street, they make deliveries, hence the best pizza in NYC.

Prince Street Pizza address

27 Prince St, New York, NY 10012

Prince Street Pizza Contacts

+1 (212)-966-4100

John’s Pizzeria

This famous pizza spot has a Google rating of 4.5 stars after more than 8k reviews.

John’s is the classic for those looking for the famous pizza in NYC. Walking into this space feels like stepping back in time. This is because the place is filled with history and noise from the locals and visitors who fill this place at its core. You can order deep-dish pizza, one of the most satisfying here. It comes with a sturdy and thick crust and sensible cheese amounts.

They have a significant investment tradition, which is evident in their pies. You share the calzone with friends while sharing the round dining tables for that memorable experience.

John’s Pizzeria Address

260 West 44th Street, New York, New York 10036

John’s Pizzeria Contacts

+1 (212) 391-7560

Rubirosa

Located in Manhattan, Rubirosa has a Google rating 4.6 with over 4500 reviews.

Rubirosa has a special place in my heart! This NYC pizza spot has Delicious pizza, a fantastic ambiance, and a vibe. They have good staff and decent prices to avoid breaking the pockets in case the craving kicks in. I love the many options and two sizes for 14 and 18-inch pies. The crust is thin, and the sauces are a unique, flavorful combo. Also, they have a sizeable mock-tail menu.

Additionally, take advantage of the gourmet options where you can try Vodka Sauce Pizza, which is worth the calories!

Rubirosa Address

235 Mulberry St, New York, NY 10012

Rubirosa contacts

+1 (212)-965-0500

Bleecker Street Pizza

Bleecker Street Pizza has a google rating of 4.5 stars after more than 5k reviews.

Bleecker’s special is the white pizza loaded with ricotta and mozzarella. The flavors are cooked with professionalism, and the crust is beautifully melded to bring that crunch of a lifetime. When finding the best pizza in New York City, Bleecker Street is hard to beat.

They dedicate themselves to providing the best freshly priced ingredients. You can order, dine, or takeout- the feeling is still satisfying.

Bleecker Street Pizza Address

69 7th Ave S, New York, NY 10014

Bleecker Street Pizza Contacts

+1 (212)-924-4466

Lucali

This pizzeria has a Google rating of 4.2 stars after more than 2k reviews.

The atmosphere here is welcoming, perfect for a date spot. Even though they don’t do deliveries, it’s an excellent spot to pass by and quench your thirst while you stroll the city. From the reviews, many people praise the Neapolitan pizza, which is heavenly. Their crust is perfectly charred, and the toppings are disciplined as well.

Each pie bite comes with love here since it’s served by friendly professionals who tell you the best flavor.

Lucali Address

575 Henry St, Brooklyn, NY 11231

Di Fara Pizza

Di Fara has a Google rating of 4.2 stars after more than 4k reviews.

Di Fara Pizza is legendary for a reason! I finally tried the famous Di Fara Pizza and now understand why it is ranked among the best. They serve the most thin and crispy slices with almost no flop. They top it with a balanced salty and savory sauce. Their cheese did not dominate the slice, yet it complimented the sauce and crust.

Also, there are few toppings or other types of slices to choose from, eliminating a lot of decision-making. The good thing is that everything they serve comes out of the oven fresh right before you.

Di Fara Pizza Address

1424 Avenue J, Brooklyn, NY 11230

Di Fara Pizza Contacts

+1 (718)-258-1367

Prince Street Pizza

Its Google rating is 4.4 stars with over 7500 reviews.

Prince Street Pizza is an NYC pizza staple. After trying their famous Spicy Pepperoni Square, I can see why it’s so popular. Though I tried it once, the square slice has a thick yet perfectly crispy crust holding up to the sauce and cheese layer. Prince Street Pizza is a must-try if you’re a fan of dense, flavorful pizza and especially love a good pepperoni slice.

The spot is small and can get pretty crowded, but the fast-moving line is worth the wait. It’s the kind of place where you grab your slice and enjoy it outside while soaking in the vibe of NYC.

Prince Street Pizza Address

27 Prince St, New York, NY 10012

Prince Street Pizza Contacts

+1 (212)-966-4100

John’s of Bleecker Street

John’s of Bleecker Street has a Google rating of 4.6 stars after more than 6k reviews.

As you explore and taste the best pizza in NYC, be sure to come across this spot: John’s of Bleecker Street. Whether you are craving a classic Margherita, a top-filled Meat lover, or a BBQ Chicken, this spot has a spot for you. Part of their rules are that they don’t have reservations and no slices, just whole pizzas alone! It’s the perfect spot for family or friends to enjoy the pizza.

The pizza is absolute perfection, and the atmosphere is fun! Prices range from $20 to $30.

John’s of Bleecker Street Address

278 Bleecker St, New York, NY 10014

John’s of Bleecker Street Contacts

+1 (212)-243-1680

Check Out

  1. Top 10 Best Picnic Spots in NYC
  2. Top 10 New York Beaches
  3. 10 Fun Amusement Parks in New York
  4. 10 Best Barbershops in NYC
  5. 10 of the Best Places for Camping in New York

Leave a Comment